Friday, July 30, 2010

Lie Angle: Will It Change?

I was speaking to Ken at PPGS.com Customer Service and he asked me to comment on a question a customer called in to ask. Since he changed from a rotational swing to the PPGS limited turn vertical swing and was doing well with it, the customer asked, “Do I need to change the lie angle on my irons because I’m now swinging more vertically?”

If I could have spoken to him the first come back question I would ask him how his swing was, how he was hitting the ball, and how were his divots? If his answers were ok to good to swing, impact and divots are OK to good, then I would say his lie angles are probably fine. But I would still delve a little deeper in the following questions and points to be evaluated and considered.

The first and most important issue to deal with is the present lie of his irons. If they have been set to fit him and he has been hitting the ball well after changing to the PPGS, that is solid and with the ball flight trajectory and shape he likes and wants, then I would say he is probably ok leaving them as is.

The way to check your lie angle is: First, you need someone to help you as you are going to do a static lie angle check. Take your stance and setup with any iron and have your helper slide a piece of paper (business cards work well because they are rigid) under the heel of the club and slide it forward toward the center. Then from the toe, slide it toward the center. If the lie angle is correct the card should slide from the heel inward a little just short of the center and from the toe it should slide almost to the center.

Sliding the card from the heel inward, if it cannot get to near the center, the lie angle is likely too upright, especially if the card barely slides forward and definitely if the card can’t slide inward at all. Not being able to slide the card inward from the toe to the center is showing that the lie angle is too flat. In both cases the lie angle needs to be adjusted to correct the lie to where the card slides inward from the heel and toe to the center.

Many PGA Professionals and club fitters use hitting off a lie board, with tape on the bottom to check the scuff marks on the tape to determine if the club is bottoming out too much on the heel or toe and needs to be adjusted. I am not a big believer in the lie board because for one, it is hitting the width of the board above ground contact and is not going lower, as a divot would, into the ground after contact with the ball, even with the shallow divots I like to see. Because of these two issues, I believe lie boards do not give a true impact reading. That is why I have an expression about lie boards that goes like this. “Why do you think they call it Lie Board? It Lies.”

Now, a big point to consider is that if you get a good static reading (the one I believe the most because it is your natural arm extension in a real close to impact position) and then do a lie board analysis and the lie board shows scuff marks on the heel or toe, you now need to consider that you have shaft flex issues involved as the problem.

Another issue the customer has to consider is the depth of his divots. If your divots are relatively the same depth, and definitely not deeper, then you are OK with the same lie. Also to consider regarding your divots is that they are the same depth from heel to toe. That is the divot is level, the same depth across it from the heel to the toe. This is a key that will tell if your lie angle is correct. It the divot is deeper on either side, it means that your lie angle is off and needs to be adjusted. Again, if your static measurement is Ok and a lie board impact is bad, you have to start looking at your shaft flex and kick point.

But as I said in the beginning of this article, if you are hitting the irons well in the beginning, you’ll t likely have the correct shaft flex and kick point and only need to check for lie angle. This would mean a static setup check with the business card is good and is compared to your divots. Hitting the irons poorly means the first issue is checking and finding out the correct shaft length, flex and kick points, and then checking your lie angle. Any PGA pro and club fitter will always check lie angles after re-shafting. If they don’t you need to ask. It is another process and they may charge you a nominal fee per club or reduced rate for the whole set. But, it is a necessary and must do check-up. Perfect length and shaft flex can all be ruined with bad lie angles in any or all of your irons.

Now, re-capping the original question as to whether changing to the PPGS automatically needs a lie angle chang, the simple answer is NO, as long as your irons fit you before and after the swing change and your ball striking and divots are good.

The Surge!

Post to Twitter Tweet This Post

.

Please Leave Me Your Comments & Questions!

Tell me what you're thinking... and what part of the golf swing, or this great game... you'd like to know more about. If you want your pic to show with your comment, go get a gravatar!

IMPORTANT: the purpose of this comment section is to foster constructive conversation about improving our blog reader's golf game. This area is NOT designed to answer customer support questions. If you have questions about a purchase or gaining access to our private members area, please contact our customer support team at 800-603-2706 (8:00AM to 6:00PM MST, Monday Through Friday) or click here for email support. We have a new team handling support and they are very good! Please also read the FAQs below as your first course of action.

"The Surge"

Top "Frequently Asked Questions":

Question: I haven't received the product(s) I ordered.

Answer: If you ordered the PPGS Foundations Video Series, or any combination of lesson videos, it's important to understand that these are delivered in a "digital format" in our secure members only area, click here to login and access this valuble content immediately. If you have never logged in before, simply click on the "First Time User?" link at the bottom of the login page and follow the instructions.

The main advantages to this delivery method are; (a) you have access to the content immediately after ordering, (b) you have several different formats that you can view the videos in (including downloadable formats you can burn to DVD and/or put right on your iPhone, or other smart phone, to take them to the practice range and (c) you will get new versions of any products that we revise and/or improve for free without having to wait for updates to be delivered to you through the postal mail.

IMPORTANT: if you want actual hard copy DVDs sent to your home, you can call our customer support team at 800-603-2706 (8:00AM to 6:00PM MDT, Monday Through Friday) and they can get those shipped right out to you for the price of shipping and handling.


Question: I received 1 or more of the 10 free videos, but I'm missing 1 or more. How do I get the free videos that I'm missing?

Answer: You can simply follow this link, put in the email address that you originally signed up with... and you'll be able to view them immediately: http://members.peakperformancegolfswing.com/LostFreeVideos.aspx


Question: I emailed customer service and I never got a response back. How do I get support?

Answer: Unfortantely, email is not a perfect system. If our support team has received your email, they have responded to it... their reply just might not have made it all the way to your email "inbox". If you still need assistance on ANYTHING, please call our customer support team at 800-603-2706 (8:00AM to 6:00PM MDT, Monday Through Friday) and they will take care of you.


  • Bob Ferguson
    Last year I was fitted for a new set of clubs by a pro at one of our local courses. The lie of the irons was determined to be one degree upright based on my swing using a lie board (which you apparently are not a fan of). Regular flex shafts were ordered based on my swing speed of approximately 100 mph. From one of your previous blogs, you suggest sets of clubs may indeed be mislabeled, and consequently recommend they be verified by a club fitter. Maybe I'm being naive, but I'd like to think this happens far less often than you allude to.
  • Rich Carione
    Don,

    Last week I called and was told the DVD version of your system was about $10.00 more than the online version. at about $90.00 No problem.

    This morning I received your email offer to buy the system for half off. I clicked on the link in the email and got to the page explaining the offer, and saw the photo of the DVDs. I called to order the DVD version and was told that the half off offer was for the online version only.

    WHAT'S UP WITH THAT?!!!!!!!!!
    I'm ready to buy your product for half off the original DVD price, including the 5 bonos DVDs. AS IT IS PICTURED ON YOUR WEB SITE!!

    If you will honor what I saw, we have a deal, and you can contact me at 626.485.5445 or at rich@gwcrystal.com and I'll place my order.

    You seem like a pretty cool guy, but I don't think it's very cool not to offer both versions at half off. YOU GOT ME TO CALL TO BUY YOUR SYSTEM AT HALF OFF!!

    How many other golfers are there out there like me, who want your system on DVD, and are ready to buy at half off, make the call to find out the offer is for the online version only?

    NOT COOL AT ALL...

    I look forward to your response

    Rich Carione
  • Robert Feagley
    Hi; Surge I enjoy your teaching of the golf swing [ Alignment check points] Don here`s my set up. From in back of the ball, I pick a line 12 to 14 inches in back of the ball thur the ball, 12 to14 inches in front of the ball on the target line That gives me 28 inches of target line to set up square to the target line. Ball centered for the short irons My take away I square club face in back of the ball, my take away to the point 14 inches back of ball on the target line. The club is on the target line. The swing plane the target line. Ball dead streight on target line. With this alignment no eliptically curve right to left. It works on all clubs give it try Robert Feagley
  • ernie peterson
    Don- I am a sceptic- tried many things with limited success. I'm interested in your approach and would like to try your offer for the instruction for $1.00. I filled out the info but it offered a bond with the order. What's with this? I don't want a bond and don't want to sign up for something I don't understand. I tried to imput "no" to the bond offer, but it wouldn't allow me to decline the offer.
    Please explain what that's about. Seems kinda fishy to me.
    Ernie Peterson
  • Dave
    Don - I purchased the DVD set and after reviewing all chapters I hit the links for the weekend. A have been working on a more upright swing for many months and PPGS helped even more, to some degree. I am sure this is a common issue but I can get more vertical on my irons but I am having a real problem with the woods. I can go toe up along the line with what feels like a natural forearm rotation but am unable to duplicate that motion with the longer clubs................. I keep flattening out.

    My question - if I go toe up with a driver and go as vertical as I can I am coming over the top. I feel as though I have to hinge my wrist to go vertical (up the tree) when I am toe up along the line. As you say - BUT too many angles wreaks havoc with contact. I am all over the place with the driver now. Yes, this is the early learning stage for PPGS and this seems to be my big glitch.
  • Yves Tremblay
    Hi Don,
    First, congratulations for the good you do with your free lessons...
    I'm about a 13 handicaper.

    Have you got a trick that could help me not to move my legs to much on the bakswing?
    Should I keep both feet on the ground when I start my backswing?

    Sometimes, I have the impression my weight is not well distributed on my legs...causing the problem that my legs are moving too much...and then, on the downswing, my hips are moving to fast compare to my shoulders...

    In other words, it gives me the impressionmthat my shoulders and my arms are not going through the ball at the same time as my hips. My hips are opening too fast towards the target.

    Should I put more pressure on my legs in a way they won't be moving too much...
  • Tim
    I have trouble with my transition with excess lateral slide towards the target. Starting the forward sing motion from a 2/3 back swing, I start from the ground up, pushing off with my right foot. At impact, I have moved in front of the ball creating a ball flight starting right of the target and never coming back. I am afraid that I will start a reverie pivot in my forward swing to start the ball on line.
    What are your thoughts and drills to correct this problem?
  • Micahel
    I have been playing golf for about three years now. After trying out the PPGS, In the three weeks I've been using it I have noticed that my scores are noticably lower. Just last week I hit a 69 at my local par 62 executive course (normally I'm in the 80's), and, I am hitting an average of 85 at the longer par 72 course I play. Normally my scores are in the mid 90's at that course. My handicap index trend is headed south needless to say, which has been my goal. It is still higher than what I think my potential is, but, I am happy with the overall progress I have made since using you techniques. My goal is to hit in the mid 70's consistently, and, agfter the progress I've made, I realy believe that this swing is the best path to get me there. I still make mistakes but for the most part my iron shots are going straighter when I execute with consistancy. My driver shots still need work, but, they are going longer when they do go straight (I hit about 10 fairways this past weekend which i was happy with) . Practice makes perfect as the saying goes. Thanks,
  • Micahel
    I have been playing golf for about three years now. After trying out the PPGS, In the three weeks I've been using it I have noticed that my scores are noticably lower. Just last week I hit a 69 at my local par 62 executive course (normally I'm in the 80's), and, I am hitting an average of 85 at the longer par 72 course I play. Normally my scores are in the mid 90's at that course. My handicap index trend is headed south needless to say, which has been my goal. It is still higher than what I think is my potential is, but, I am happy with the overall progress I have made since using you techniques. My goal is to hit in the mid 70's consistently, and, agfter the progress I've made, I realy believe that this swing is the best path to get me there. I still make mistakes but for the most part my iron shots are going straighter when I execute with consistancy. My driver shots still need work, but, they are going longer when they do go straight (I hit about 10 fairways this past weekend which i was happy with) . Practice makes perfect as the saying goes. Thanks,
  • Doug
    Hi Don

    I've tried to changed from a rotational swing to the PPGS limited turn vertical swing. The swing works fine for my irons but I keep popping up the ball with my Driver. Can you tell me what I/m doing wrong?
  • Christopher
    Hi Don,

    I noticed you said "I believe lie boards do not give a true impact reading" and and also said "it is hitting the width of the board above ground contact and is not going lower, as a divot would, into the ground after contact with the ball".

    I beliecve that the inpact is actually above ground? Due to that the divot, etc after the impact is actually the follow through isn't it?

    Anyway, it is always very interesting to hear what the Surge has to say.

    Thank you
  • Jeff Casper
    To all the detractors out there. I started Don's method 6 weeks ago and after diligent practice,( like 8 whole hours) I have complete confidence in my swing and where the ball is going. It's great to not have to worry where the ball will end up. THANK YOU DON!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Oh yeah by the way I'm 6'2" 195 lbs 47 yrs old and hit a 320 yd drive yesterday!!! Irons are straight and right at the pin. I love it!!!!!
  • Bob Foley
    I have been considering ordering your video serious as I think they would help my game, however if I would be required to view your video's on line instead of you sending me DVD's that I can watch on my TV/ DVD player, I would be inclined not to purchase them because I live in a area that does not have axcess to high speed internet service but rather dial- up service which is so very slow. It takes forever to download the video's that you have been emailing to me these past nine days.

    Thanks for the nine that you sent to me, looking forward to number ten which I thought would have been in my email this morning. I have enjoyed all nine video's and the many letters and coments that came with them. I am hitting the driver down the middle, but only 150-160 yards. Would like to hit it 180 plus, though I have not be able to do so for several years, I am 74 and not very flexiable so I have been using a 3/4 back swing or less for some time. Thanks Again, look forward to your reply.
    Bob
  • Kelly
    I am not part of the PPGS staff. I'm just a long time student of the game, so take my answers for what they are worth.

    To DAVID STOCKWELL: Yes you are on track. There are some small subtleties about the swing, the plane, the exact path of the hands, etc. that we could discuss ad nauseum, but your new thinking is basically correct. A "vertical" swing is not a meant to be a literal description. As you have noted, a perfectly vertical swing is anatomically impossible. The club nor the hand/arms can ever be perfectly vertical (likewise, a perfectly horizontal swing is impossible because it would be done horizontally at shoulder height - well, I guess you could just buy really, really long tees, but...). A vertical swing is simply "more vertical" than a rotational, "horizontal" swing.

    I think you are also right to only think about the position of your hands and arms. When I think of plane, I like to only watch/feel where my arms, wrists, and hands are and the path they are following. I figure if these components of the swing are in the proper positions, the club will just do its thing.

    To LEE OVENS: I think Don said that the standard shaft length of OFF THE SHELF drivers is 45 to 46". He was not advocating this, but was, in fact, arguing against it. The point Don was making reflects your concerns -- most of us have no business swinging a 45 to 46" driver. It is simply too long for us. I once read a quote from Justin Leonard in which he said his driver is something like 44" long because he can't control anything longer. He went on to say that he couldn't believe that so many amateurs were trying to swing 46" driver when he and most of the tour players can't control drivers that are nearly that long.

    I suggest getting yourself fitted (that goes for your irons, too). Have your clubs fit for length and flex (along with a few other variables). Be aware that you can't simply cut your own driver to length in your garage. I realize that this is easy to do and you may even get it to the proper length. However, in doing so you change other characteristics of the club and shaft, including weighting, shaft flex, kick point, etc. Keep in mind, this isn't a panacea -- just because you get your clubs fitted doesn't mean you are going to magically begin playing great golf. But if your equipment fits, your chances of playing your best golf possible are better. Also, if you aren't playing well, you know that it is your swing that you need to work on and not your equipment.

    To JAMES: Bye.
  • James
    Wow, after reading this and your flawed philosophy on club fitting... i will definitely NOT be purchasing your videos or reading anymore of your garbage emails.
  • Emil S Kapcar
    Don,

    You did not mention the the test should be done on a hard surface like wood, linoleum, rubber or concrete.

    This would certainly not work on grass or soft ground at a practice range.

    Emil
  • LEE OVENS
    Surge
    I read Ur articles on the length of the driver and u said the standard is 45 and 46 inches
    Point me out if I ‘am wrong, but I believe this is a measurement for a giant,
    I ‘am 1650 meters or as u would say 5ft5in, I am one of those people that does not get served at a busy bar because I ‘am so tall, they can’t see me, anyway back 2 the question,
    I have always thought my drivers are 2 long
    Because of my height I reckon my driver should be around the same length as my 3 or 5 wood would this be correct or wrong, what r Ur thoughts
    LEE OVENS
    BRISBANE
    AUSTRALIA
  • Bob
    What is the T finish? Bob
  • Walt George
    Don, I have practiced a few times, and I have seen my irons, although not very consistant,
    fly straight as an arrow. It feels awkward because it goes against everything we were ever
    taught about the golf swing. I feel with more practice, I will be able to use your swing to
    my advantage. ( BUT ) I am having a difficult time with the driver. The swing feels awfull,
    and the results are the same. Do you have any tips & practice drills that can help me to
    gain some consistancy with my driver? Thank you, Walt.
  • Norman Jones
    Don,

    I have to disagree a little bit on your lie angle (board) statement. Most folks, rightly or wrongly, do not impact the ball with their hands in the same position as at address. For most golfers, the hands are higher at impact and further from thier belt buckles. This impact position will be more upright than a static lie measurement would suggest. The only way to know what the lie of the club is at impact (the only time that really matters) is to use a lie board for dynamic measurement. I do agree that there is a built-in inaccuracy with this method: If the measured impact is dead center, it would indicate that the lie angle on the iron is slightly "flat".
    A clubfitter worth his pay will certainly check and consider shaft flex (and length, by the way) BEFORE making any lie adjustments on the iron clubhead.

    Love your stuff. Keep those great tips coming!

    norman
  • Rod Reynolds
    Don,
    Who ultimately picks which questions will get answered. One unhappy cow!
    Rod
  • Mr. Surge : I beg to differ with your "static" way of LIE ANGLE FITTING. Most golfers but enough shaft bend [Load} on the down swing that a dynamic fitting is necessary. The Toe drupes enough to cause a difference in the lie angle. This is my opinion .
  • Gerald Evans
    Don

    Since starting your course my swing is getting smoother and easier and my hits are starting to
    be straighter.

    On the other hand - I am not getting any distance. My driver gets me a wimpy 150, maybe 175. All other clubs seem to be relative distance wise. Of course I need practice but do you have any words of wisdom here? The lack of distance is very FRUSTRATING.

    Thank you!



    Gerald Evans
  • David Stockwell
    Surge/Don,

    Regarding the Lie Angle question, I found that I had a misunderstanding of how the vertical swingplane would work, and thought (for a short and painful time) that the plane of the whole club was vertical through impact. This resulted in my hard-grounding the club as it tried to pass right by my toe line, resulting in severe tendon pain in my "leading" elbow...(ouch!).

    In fact (and as I am sure you intended to point out), as the club comes through the downswing, the hands stay more-or-less on the vertical plane, and the hands also rotate so the club-head leaves the vertical plane to impact the ball roughly (in me) 18 inches from my toe line...where I addressed the ball. At impact, the club should then end up on the lie angle it had when I addressed the ball. From there, my hands follow through to end up by my leading (left) shoulder as I face the target balanced on my left, front foot.

    In all of this, am I correct in my analysis, or am I still "off"?

    All the best,

    DS
  • Michael Thongstad
    Surge,
    I have been playing this ever challenging game of golf for years...searching constantly for a workable swing...I saw your intro video and I must say...."THANKS" ...My game has improved and so has my confidence in standing over the ball...and with no back muscle issue...I am 55 and now can play 36 holes without needing a hot tub and therapy.... The physics of the dynamic balance is dead on...my ball flight is straight and even miss hits the ball goes straighter....thanks for a swing that will take my game to the next level....what is more amazing is that this simple swing does not take years of practice to see results...they are almost immediate....
  • I'm not sure most amateurs should be worried about their lie angel is as much as they should be trying to simplify the swing. I would venture to guess that most don't even know what a lie angle is, much less if they should change it. I do believe like you that the divot should tell the story.

    Come see us at: http://www.aboutjuniorgolf.com

    See my video on how to find the right golf ball for you.
blog comments powered by Disqus
10 FREE VIDEO LESSONS
Need Help? Have Questions? Click Here For Live Chat Help!
Don’s Putting Video System:
Recent Comments
Don’s Driver Video Series
Recent Posts
Don’s Inner Circle Membership